Imager's Challenge by L. E. Modesitt

Synopsis: Imager’s Challenge takes up immediately after the conclusion of Imager. Still recovering from injuries received in foiling the plots of the Ferran envoy, Rhenn is preparing to take up his new duties as imager liaison to the Civic Patrol of L’Excelsis. No sooner has he assumed his new position than he discovers two things. First, the Commander of the Civic Patrol doesn’t want a liaison from the infamous Collegium, and soon has Rhenn patrolling the streets of the worst district in the city. Second, Rhenn receives formal notice that one of the High Holders, the father of a man Rhenn partly blinded in self-defense, has declared his intention to destroy Rhenn and his family.


Rhenn’s only allies are the family of the girl he loves, successful merchants with underworld connections. In the end, Rhenn must literally stand off against gang lords, naval marines, Tiempran terrorist priests, the most powerful High Holder in all of Solidar, and his own Collegium—and find a way to prevail without making further enemies and endangering those he loves.

Warning: Spoilers

Imager’s Challenge is the second book in this series. It doesn’t move as quickly as many other fantasy novels, but I don’t mind. I have read almost all of Modesitt’s Recluce stories so much of the progression wasn’t a surprise. But for all that, I liked it very much.

I expected Rhenn to kill his enemies. Mind, I didn’t expect him to kill the High Holder by destroying the building he was standing on. I thought he wouldn’t be quite that drastic because that kind of thing could get other Holders and/or their children killed and that would have put in the middle of aa feud (maybe even multiple feuds!) yet again. It didn’t; the imagers somehow managed to work that to their advantage – after telling Rhenn repeatedly he must do nothing that led directly back to the imagers! But I wasn’t surprised when he did and I knew High Holder’s daughter would inherit the holding. I knew that was going to happen since they danced.

What I like best about this series is the magic system. It is unusual. Being able to imagine things into being, well, it just sounds so good. It works, too, because there are limits on what can be imagined and how. Nothing comes from nothing, after all, and everything has a cost, even if it is just in energy.

What I disliked about Imager’s Challenge is that Rhenn spends a lot of time complaining. Complaining that the imagers won’t help him and aren’t interested in what he knows if he has no proof, proof he has no way of getting. I get it and and I get that its not fair. But it got old half way through the book.

Book: B-